FICO is very happy with the Tray Platform’s flexibility. The platform’s ability to push data has empowered us to drastically improve marketing processes.
Caryn, Senior Consumer Marketing Manager, FICO
Automatically updates lead and email lists to reduce reliance on manually managing flat files
Integrates data warehouse to Marketo to port updated customer and production data into Marketo for one view of opt-in preferences as a consolidated view of engagement
Increases email deliverability rates 30%, open rates 26%, and click-through rates 9% through cleaner, timelier data
Provides opportunities for future improvements in consolidating customer and lead data and in honing more-relevant marketing messaging
A leading provider of data analytics and credit scoring, the company has thousands of employees who work daily to help people use data to make better decisions. The company’s consumer division offers numerous products that enable users to access their FICO® scores, the industry-standard credit score, get credit reports from all three credit bureaus, get identity theft protection, and find lower rates on important expenditures such as mortgage and auto payments.
FICO’s Consumer Team set out to engage consumer audiences with practical, everyday financial services and useful educational materials, but it faced some technology challenges that were overcome with forward-thinking teamwork and integration of state-of-the-art technology.
In its earliest days, FICO’s Consumer Team relied on digital communication software that was not integrated to any of its internal data sources. This meant that each marketing campaign required the team to re-invent the proverbial wheel by manually loading target lists and verifying them each time – a time-consuming process that also reduced response rates.
“We had to add flat files into the system in order to do email campaigns. The list of emails itself would need to be set up manually,” recalls Senior Consumer Marketing Manager Caryn Ryan. “Even just to set up cross-sells or emailing a newsletter, we had to have someone write a script to pull the lead information from our database into a text file.”
“Unfortunately, our digital communication software was never updated, so it wasn’t a source of truth at all. It was where we’d put the files to immediately send out, and never use again. It wasn’t connected to unsubscribes, customer information, engagement information, or anything else. It ended up just being dead data.”
The team recognized this problem and decided to make a change. It ultimately made the decision to switch to Marketo, the popular marketing automation platform (MAP). Marketo allowed the team to automate the management of its various marketing campaigns, including complicated processes like newsletter unsubscribe requests.
“The development team was also migrating to a new solution for data warehousing, which meant we could start getting access to our data a bit more broadly than we could previously,” explains Ryan. “That allowed us to start thinking about an automation tool that would actually be connected to our back-end data.”
There was just one problem. While each of these solutions is good at what it does, there was no native integration to connect the tools to provide the specific functionality that the FICO team needed. This meant that, despite having excellent tools on hand, the team would still have to transfer flat files of marketing data among the various components of its marketing stack - a process that is highly inefficient, prone to user error and is too time-consuming. The team recognized this unique challenge and put several ideas in place to solve the problems it faced.
The Consumer Team realized that it needed a user-friendly, common-sense solution that would not tie up internal engineering teams. So the team searched for state-of-the-art platform solutions that would allow it to connect its marketing tools.
“The consumer team is relatively small, so we needed something that could manage API connections with very little oversight,” explains Ryan. “Like many organizations, we have a lot of demand on our engineering resources. We can’t really have developers working full-time on internal processes or managing APIs. Instead, we need to focus development not only on our products and services but also on our back-end infrastructure. We’re a financial services company, so there’s a big focus on security.”
These considerations ultimately led the FICO team to Tray.io’s General Automation Platform, which connects leading software applications and flows important business data seamlessly among them with a code-free, drag-and-drop interface that any business user can use.
The implementation of Tray’s platform led to great success. Using the Tray platform, FICO’s Consumer Marketing and Developer Teams sidestepped the need to implement APIs to connect its marketing stack. Thus, the team synced Marketo to its data warehouse to pull lead and customer data directly from their back end, which allowed it to automatically consolidate and de-dupe its marketing lead lists. It also allowed the team to create a single source of truth for marketing preferences within Marketo.
The team manages customer data as well as engagement data from its production environment. The FICO team ports this data to a table in its data warehouse solution, and using the Tray platform, provides regular intraday data updates to Marketo.
In the end, the team’s hard work and problem-solving led to vast improvements, including greater engagement rates within email campaigns, as well as saved time within the team.
“We’re very happy with the Tray platform’s flexibility,” says Ryan. The Tray platform has enabled her team to make significant process changes that have saved time and led to noticeable progress towards its goals.
“With our systems connected via Tray.io, we’ve been able to use and see our data much more easily. Just the act of consolidating user subscription preferences has been a huge improvement, one that we can see reflected in our massive improvement in deliverability rates.”
“Having up-to-date, correct data has been game changing: our data is cleaner, fresher, and we’ve been able to leverage that in our communications, from nurture campaigns to triggered campaigns. Implementing the Tray platform has definitely improved deliverability for our campaigns from approximately 60% of emails landing in inboxes to about 90% in inboxes. Our engagement rates spiked overall with open rates increasing by about 26% and click-through rates by about 9%," Ryan states.
“Finally, we’ve also seen significant time savings as we spend less time manually handling our data: writing SQL, or pulling and de-duping flat files of marketing data, which the Tray platform automatically ports through our data warehouse to Marketo for us. The platform’s ability to push data back and forth has empowered us to drastically improve marketing processes.”
Looking ahead and using the success of this implementation the FICO team plans to make use of Tray platform to seamlessly route data to and from different sources. “Something we want to do in the future is to connect a lot of disparate data sources, both first-party and third-party. We work with many different vendors, so we’d like to consolidate and create one view of our leads and customers,” explains Ryan.
“In the future, the goal is to provide marketing messaging that’s much more relevant, by integrating data from sources like Google AdWords or our own Forums. We want to offer a lot more relevant content to get our customers engaged with our products and their credit.”